Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: Treason and Sedition Party will be on the record today

NBC:

This chaotic moment has one root cause: Trump's refusal to accept his loss

First Read is your briefing from "Meet the Press" and the NBC Political Unit on the day's most important political stories and why they matter.

The president begging Georgia’s secretary of state to overturn the election results … More than 140 House and Senate Republicans objecting to the Electoral College count … Trump addressing supporters in Washington (“You will have an illegitimate president … And we can't let that happen.”) … Many of those supporters later storming the Capitol … Trump saying that he won’t attend the inauguration (and getting banned from Twitter) … The drafting of articles of impeachment … And now authorities warning of more armed protests.

All of these events have taken place in just the last 10 days.

And of all them have a simple root cause — the president of the United States refusing to concede an election he clearly lost. (Yes, he acknowledged there would be a new administration and a transition of power, but that’s as far as he’s gone.)

We still need to work on whether there were higher-ups involved with Wednesday’s abysmal law enforcement response.

Good luck to house republicans struggling to figure out how to vote on impeachment tomorrow cause trump didn’t give you anything to work with here https://t.co/ahu6SWj4eq

— jim manley (@jamespmanley) January 12, 2021

Amy Davidson Sorkin/New Yorker:

A Second Trump Impeachment Could Answer More Questions About the Attack on the Capitol

Kevin McCarthy, the House Minority Leader, who voted to reject the Electoral College votes of Arizona and Pennsylvania, is among those Republicans now complaining that impeachment is divisive. (In a private, closed-door meeting of the House Republican caucus, McCarthy reportedly acknowledged that Trump has some responsibility for what happened on January 6th—a pathetic half-gesture that only raises the question of why McCarthy seems afraid to hold the President to account in public, and whether he is ready to renounce his own votes to overturn the Electoral College.) As Jamelle Bouie observed, in the Times, this sentiment is better understood as a threat to the country than as a desire for unity. The process will be as divisive or as unifying as the Republicans allow it to be. Seen from another angle, Pelosi is offering her Republican colleagues a chance to come together in a bipartisan way to make the point that the President should not instruct a crowd to march down Pennsylvania Avenue and “fight like hell”—a phrase quoted in the article of impeachment—against the certification of the legitimate winner of the election. Only a handful of House Republicans, notably Adam Kinzinger, of Illinois; Peter Meijer, of Michigan; and Liz Cheney, of Wyoming, seem likely to seize the opportunity—last week, after all, a majority of Republican House members voted to effectively disenfranchise the voters of Arizona and Pennsylvania. (Over the weekend, Meijer wrote of speaking to a colleague who said that he was objecting to the Electoral College tally only because he feared for the safety of his family.) But these are unpredictable days.

One way or another, it seems improbable that any trial in the Senate would begin before Trump leaves office. Even so, it would hardly be moot. In addition to removal from office, an available penalty after conviction is disqualification from holding federal office in the future; Trump could be barred from running in 2024. Again, a conviction would require a two-thirds majority of the Senate, which the Democrats don’t have. But the contours of the trial, and what might be revealed in the course of it, are not yet clear. There is much that we don’t know about what happened last week in Washington, and that we still need to know.

New: Group pledges up to $50 million to defend Republicans who support impeaching Trump https://t.co/Ypxg3JIFaY

— Annie Karni (@anniekarni) January 12, 2021

BuzzFeed:

There’s A Straight Line From Charlottesville To The Capitol

Wednesday’s attempted coup is just the natural extension of a presidency spent giving insurgents permission to come inside, kick their feet up, and tear down democracy.

That sense of open invitation was the mood for most of the day, even hours later, when the National Guard arrived in the evening to disperse what was left of the crowd. The rioters’ entrance into the Capitol building and Senate offices was casual, easy, with surprisingly little conflict for a group of people who were attempting a deadly coup in one of the largest democracies in the world. Even before Congress reconvened to finish the certification vote, there was plenty of hand-wringing about how this armed insurrection wasn’t reflective of the country. “This is wrong,” tweeted Rep. Nancy Mace, a Republican from South Carolina. “This is not who we are.” But, really, if something simultaneously shocking and woefully unsurprising happens — with a near-immediate justification and approval from the president — maybe it’s time to accept that this is exactly what America has always been.

Huffington Post reports at least 9 Republicans refused to wear masks while huddled in secure room during the riots.https://t.co/ossgD01tQM

— Steven Dennis (@StevenTDennis) January 12, 2021

Richard North Patterson/Bulwark:

The Political Context of the Assault on the Capitol

Bonfires of grievance and dispossession in a country riven by alternate realities.

Demographic sorting and racial and cultural antagonisms have enlisted Trump’s base in a zero-sum war of subjugation against antagonists most will never meet, but with whom they can never compromise. A society so polarized cannot deal with its most urgent problems—or even acknowledge what they are.

Amid the ravages of COVID this schism has turned deadly: The resistance to public health measures has become a form of suicide which doubles as a lethal attack on others. More broadly, the political stasis bred of division is killing our capacity to master our collective future. Inevitably, such a system will disintegrate—or explode.

The paralysis reflects a deeper social pathology with multiple tributaries—the toxins of racial and cultural estrangement; the disintegration of communal bonds; the proliferation of mind-numbing misinformation; the accelerating gaps in wealth and opportunity; the increasingly ossified class system—which, in turn, erode faith in democracy as a means of resolving our problems. Running through this is the crabbed doctrine of shareholder capitalism which reduces human beings to disposable units of production divorced from the conditions that give life dignity: health, safety, security, opportunity.

US Chamber of Commerce says some lawmakers will lose its support due to their actions last week (certification) and in the week ahead (impeachment). Candidates that show respect for Democratic institutions and norms will have its backing.

— Alan Rappeport (@arappeport) January 12, 2021

Nicholas Grossman/Arc Digital:

F*** You, Ted Cruz

You un-American, anti-democracy, lying sack of sh*t

“Liar or believer?” is often hard to answer. Trump-loving Congressmen Matt Gaetz and Jim Jordan, Fox personality Sean Hannity, MAGA “youth activist” Charlie Kirk, and President Trump himself seem to really believe some of it (though can’t possibly believe it all).

With Ted Cruz it’s easy. There’s no doubt that the Republican Senator from Texas is fully aware that Trumpist claims of mass voter fraud are complete and utter bunk. He’s a Harvard-educated attorney, clerked for Chief Justice William Rehnquist, and taught law at UT Austin. He knows that Team Trump lost 61 court cases in their effort to overturn state election results, winning only one (a Pennsylvania case with no effect on the outcome). He knows, contra Trump’s whining, that lack of standing is a perfectly legitimate reason for courts to reject a case. And he knows that the time for legal challenges is over now that states have recounted and audited their votes, and certified Electoral College results.

if anyone didn’t get it before, the violent end to the Trump era brought into sharper focus something about the previous era: namely, how much of the ferocious resistance President Obama faced wasn’t standard ideological or partisan conflict but rather white reactionary backlash

— John Harwood (@JohnJHarwood) January 11, 2021

Nicholas Grossman/Arc Digital:

QAnon Woke Up the Real Deep State

An open letter to QAnon, “stop the steal,” and other communities involved in the Capitol attack

To the QAnon community, and others involved in storming the Capitol:

The Deep State is real, but it’s not what you think. The Deep State you worry about is mostly made up; a fiction, a lie, a product of active imaginations, grifter manipulations, and the internet. I’m telling you this now because storming the Capitol building has drawn the attention of the real Deep State — the national security bureaucracy — and it’s important you understand what that means.

You attacked America. Maybe you think it was justified — as a response to a stolen election, or a cabal of child-trafficking pedophiles, or whatever — but it was still a violent attack on the United States. No matter how you describe it, that’s how the real Deep State is going to treat it.

The impact of that will make everything else feel like a LARP.

LARP is live action role-playing. After a few more repetitions, i won’t need to keep defining it.

"Don't be so divisive or we'll have to kill more cops." https://t.co/3mmEFyYOpG

— Charlie Sykes (@SykesCharlie) January 12, 2021

Emily Gorcenski/Twitter:

Here's the challenge with disrupting militia plots: most militia dudes are Dunning-Kruger levels of incompetent, but not Dunning-Kruger levels of dangerous. 
So the problem is that militia culture is wrapped up in this sort of virtue signalling nonstop. It's all around trying to project yourself as a leader, a military expert, a tactical master, based entirely on what you've read in Tom Clancy novels 
So a militia might say things like, alright, here's the plan. We're gonna get 1000 guys, and we're gonna set up a barricade at each of the three entrances to the statehouse, and then we're gonna neutralize the security forces. 
Super scary stuff! Just one problem. Where are they gonna get 1000 guys? How are they going to implement a Command and Control structure for 1000 guys? What are they gonna make the barricades out of? 

A Senate Republican aide tells me he thinks there were about 20, give or take, Republicans who were *open* to a conviction Before our story on McConnell

— Jonathan Martin (@jmartNYT) January 12, 2021

Kurt Bardella/USA Today:

Trump doesn't deserve post-presidential benefits. Remove him and ensure he won't get them.

In spite of the U.S. Capitol siege incited by President Donald Trump, Republican leaders in Congress continue to oppose any meaningful action to hold him accountable for his seditious conduct. They seem to think that in spite of his dangerous and undemocratic behavior, he should still be the beneficiary of taxpayer-financed perks for the rest of his life.

It has become clear that Republicans are trying to run out the clock on the Trump presidency, using his short-timer status to justify their inaction. “I firmly believe impeachment would further destroy our ability to heal and start over,” tweeted Sen. Lindsey Graham, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee. House Republican Leader Kevin McCarthy maintained that impeaching Trump so close to the end of his term "will only divide our country more.”

For the record, I don’t remember Republicans in Congress worrying about healing the country when they created the Select Committee on Benghazi for the sole purpose of undermining Hillary Clinton, the Democrats' leading presidential prospect in the runup to the 2016 race. Does this mean that if there was more time in the Trump presidency,  they’d magically be for impeaching him? Last time I checked, they had the chance to impeach him a year ago, and they refused.

“As the costs of looking the other way became more apparent, the depth of the denial only grew more deeper. Now the debt is due, and the costs of indulging a wannabe tyrant will haunt the Republican party for the foreseeable future.”https://t.co/29x2Gukg9z

— Josh Kraushaar (@HotlineJosh) January 13, 2021

Caity Weaver/Twitter:

This is why we stan local news!

A West Virginia legislator streamed, then deleted, video of himself storming the capitol https://t.co/oPlBVQVKdO

— Dave Weigel (@daveweigel) January 7, 2021

Support your local paper!!!! For the love of God!!!!!

NEW: PA state Sen. Doug Mastriano and former state rep. Rick Saccone among Trump supporters who occupied U.S. Capitol. Both are known to peddle in conspiracy theories. https://t.co/jXL475AOdP

— Pittsburgh City Paper (@PGHCityPaper) January 7, 2021

🎵LoOoOcal news! Interesting news about the loOoOocals!🎵

Former Oakland Police Officer Jurell Snyder was among the mob that attacked the Capitol yesterday. In this interview he defends the attempted coup and repeats conspiracy theories about voting fraud.https://t.co/T8ziliZ5Fb

— Darwin BondGraham (@DarwinBondGraha) January 7, 2021

Tennessee said 🗣 I know that man! That’s the governor’s pastor!

JUST UP: @mort713 and I worked together to identify a short list of Tennesseeans in the DC mob yesterday, including @GovBillLee's pastor. Please take a moment to read really concerning comments, including references to 6MWE. My latest for @TNLookout. https://t.co/GOE8HaSjYR

— Abby Lee Hood (@AbbyLeeHood) January 8, 2021

Abbreviated pundit roundup: Accountability

We begin today’s roundup with analysis by John Cassidy in The New Yorker on the need for accountability in the wake of the domestic terror attack on Capitol Hill:

Despite all the outrage sparked by last week’s riot, Trump still has grounds for believing that he won’t receive any immediate sanctions for openly inciting an insurrection. It’s conceivable that he could be punished further down the road, but even that is far from certain. Repeating a tragic pattern that has been evident since he launched his first Presidential bid, in 2015, the American political system is proving too weak and divided to deal with the threat he poses. [...]

What’s required is a way to punish Trump for his sedition, make sure he can’t run for President again, and deprive him of the oxygen he so craves. The permanent ban by Twitter goes a long way toward meeting the third goal, but the first two are arguably even more important.

In other democracies, a leader who tried to overthrow an election result and incited a violent insurrection might well be cooling his heels in prison by now. In this country, the job of policing the President falls largely on the legislative branch. For four years, it has failed dismally to carry out this task. Even after the unprecedented events of last week, it’s far from clear that Congress will prove up to the task now. But this time, surely, and for the sake of American democracy, Trump must be held accountable.

Law professors Bruce Ackerman and Gerard Magliocca urge Congress to look at Section 3 of the 14th Amendment for accountability:

Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, passed in the aftermath of the Civil War, bars Trump from holding another federal office if he is found to have “engaged in insurrection or rebellion against” the Constitution of the United States. The finding could be accomplished by a simple majority vote of both houses, in contrast to the requirement in impeachment proceedings that the Senate vote to convict by a two-thirds majority. Congress would simply need to declare that Trump engaged in an act of “insurrection or rebellion” by encouraging the attack on the Capitol. Under the 14th Amendment, Trump could run for the White House again only if he were able to persuade a future Congress to, “by a vote of two-thirds of each House, remove such disability.”

More on this option from John Nichols at The Nation:

After everything that has happened over the past week, it is easy to imagine that Trump has written himself out of contention for any public office. But that is not the case. Trump is still plotting, still scheming, still campaigning—as was amply illustrated by his planned trip on Tuesday to Alamo, Tex., to highlight his crusade to erect a wall on the border between the US and Mexico.

To imagine that Trump will fade away after January 20 requires the denial of everything Americans know about the president’s massive ego, his aversion to being seen as a loser, and his determination to avenge his defeat in the 2020 election. That is why former Secretary of Labor Robert Reich and others have focused on the importance not merely of holding Trump to account for past actions but of assuring that he does not extend the threat to the republic by positioning himself as a president-in-exile after he leaves office. “We must,” says Reich, “ensure that Donald Trump can never hold public office again.”

Paul Krugman:

For a long time Republican elites imagined that they could exploit racism and conspiracy theorizing while remaining focused on a plutocratic agenda. But with the rise first of the Tea Party, then of Donald Trump, the cynics found that the crazies were actually in control, and that they wanted to destroy democracy, not cut tax rates on capital gains.

And Republican elites have, with few exceptions, accepted their new subservient status.

The Washington Post editorial board lays out the ideas being floating relating to impeachment, including delaying the trial or creating a blue-ribbon trial:

So far, much of the conversation has been about finding a way to suitably punish Mr. Trump. That is essential. But the goal must also be to provide maximum accountability with a minimum of harm to the Biden administration.

On a final note, The New York Times in its call for impeachment also calls for accountability for Trump’s enablers:

Mr. Trump may not have called directly for this behavior, but there is no question that he encouraged it and then refused for hours to condemn it, even as the whole world watched in horror. When he finally asked for rioters to stop and go home, he continued to claim the election had been stolen. [...]

ultimately, there can be no republic if leaders foment a violent overthrow of the government if they lose an election.

Mr. Trump is not the only person at fault. Many Republican lawmakers riled up his supporters for weeks with false claims of election rigging and continued to object to the electoral vote even after the attack. The 14th Amendment bars from office any federal or state lawmaker who has “engaged in insurrection or rebellion” or given “aid or comfort” to those who have. Congressional leaders will need to reckon with which of their colleagues require censure for their actions, and perhaps even expulsion.

Posted in APR

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: The deadly insurrection cosplay requires impeachment and accountability

Dan Kois/Slate:

They Were Out for Blood

The men who carried zip ties as they stormed the Capitol weren’t clowning around.

I can’t stop thinking about the zip-tie guys.

Amid the photos that flooded social media during Wednesday’s riot at the Capitol—shirtless jokers in horned helmets, dudes pointing at their nuts, dumbasses carrying away souvenirs—the images of the zip-tie guys were quieter, less exuberant, more chilling. And we’d better not forget what they almost managed to do.

It’s easy to think of the siege of the U.S. Capitol as a clown show with accidentally deadly consequences. A bunch of cosplaying self-styled patriots show up, overwhelm the incomprehensibly unprepared Capitol Police, and then throw a frat party in the rotunda. The miscreants smear shit on the walls and steal laptops and smoke weed in conference rooms. Someone gets shot; someone else has a heart attack, possibly under ludicrous circumstances. When they finally get rousted, they cry to the cameras about getting maced.

I know the coup failed because 48 hours later we’re back to “Pelosi went too far”/”Pelosi didn't go far enough.” But articles of impeachment will be drawn up this weekend and introduced as soon as Monday.

Support for Trump supporters breaking into the US Capitol via new PBS/Marist poll: All Americans: 8% support 88% oppose Republicans: 18% support 80% oppose Democrats: 3% support 96% oppose

— Ryan Struyk (@ryanstruyk) January 8, 2021

Axios:

House expected to introduce articles of impeachment next week

The House is planning to introduce articles of impeachment against President Trump as early as Monday, several sources familiar with the Democrats' plans tell Axios.

Why it matters: House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has been hearing from members across the party who want to move quickly on impeachment to hold President Trump accountable for fueling Wednesday's siege at the Capitol, especially since it's unlikely that Vice President Pence and a majority of the Cabinet will invoke the 25th Amendment.

  • No president has ever been impeached twice, but Trump is now facing that very real prospect with just 12 days left in his term.
  • If Trump is impeached by the House and convicted by the Senate, he could be barred from running for the presidency again in 2024, something that has been an attractive part of these discussions.

NEW: FBI, Homeland Security Intelligence Unit Didn’t Issue a Risk Assessment for Pro-Trump Protests At the DHS unit, called Intelligence and Analysis, management didn’t view the demonstrations as posing a significant threat, people familiar sayhttps://t.co/5csabPehGP

— Rachael Levy (@rachael_levy) January 7, 2021

Journal Sentinel:

Editorial: Ron Johnson, Scott Fitzgerald and Tom Tiffany should resign or be expelled for siding with Trump against our republic

Fitzgerald and Tiffany were the only members of the House of Representatives from Wisconsin who joined in an insurrection built upon a foundation of ignorance and lies.  

Sen. Ron Johnson decided to vote against both baseless challenges to certified votes only after our nation's Capitol was sacked as Congress gathered to perform its simple constitutional duty to recognize the Electoral College vote.

But Johnson had been shilling for Trump and this moment for days, adding kindling to the megalomaniac's fire, so his last-minute switch does nothing to absolve his role in stoking this shameful day in American history.

There are multiple photographs of pro-Trump rioters carrying law enforcement-style flex-cuffs. Rioters went looking for @VP, @SpeakerPelosi, @SenSchumer. It raises the question of whether there was an organized plan to take hostages. https://t.co/PyWfzmcddt

— Andrew Feinberg (@AndrewFeinberg) January 8, 2021

...including Deputy Chief of Staff Dan Scavino, are both active on many of those sites and very, very familiar with the pro-Trump online communities and the culture thereof. Any competent investigator will need to look into what White House officials knew and when they knew it.

— Andrew Feinberg (@AndrewFeinberg) January 8, 2021

NBC News:

Extremists made little secret of ambitions to 'occupy' Capitol in weeks before attack

On Thursday, Washington Police Chief Robert Contee said at a news conference that there was "no intelligence that suggested there would be a breach of the U.S. Capitol."

A digital flyer made public on Instagram and Facebook in December made little secret of the ambitions of some of the people planning to visit Washington on Jan. 6: “Operation Occupy the Capitol.”

That call to arms is just one of the many warning signs on extremist sites and mainstream social media platforms that extremism experts say were easy to spot but ultimately disregarded by law enforcement in the runup to Wednesday's riot at the Capitol, which led to the deaths of five people, including Capitol Police Officer Brian Sicknick, 42, who was reportedly hit with a fire extinguisher during the melee.

Washington, D.C., Attorney General Karl A. Racine told MSNBC on Friday that “there were no surprises there” when it came to what extremists prepared to do before Wednesday’s siege.

"Everyone who was a law enforcement officer or a reporter knew exactly what these hate groups were planning," Racine said. "They were planning to descend on Washington, D.C., ground center was the Capitol, and they were planning to charge and, as Rudy Giuliani indicated, to do combat justice at the Capitol,”

#BREAKING: Twitter has permanently suspended President Trump's account "due to the risk of further incitement of violence.”

— NPR Politics (@nprpolitics) January 8, 2021

Cam Wolf/GQ:

The Man Who Saw Yesterday’s Coup Attempt Coming Is Only Surprised It Wasn’t Much Worse

Arieh Kovler knew. “On January 6, armed Trumpist militias will be rallying in DC, at Trump's orders,” he wrote on Twitter on December 21st. “It's highly likely that they'll try to storm the Capitol after it certifies Joe Biden's win. I don't think this has sunk in yet.” It sank in for the rest of us yesterday, when Trumpist militias stormed the capitol. If Arieh Kovler knew, why didn’t everyone else?

We all could have, says Kovler, a political consultant with a background in government relations in the U.K. who studies extremist Trump message boards. In his telling, it wasn’t all that difficult to see the writing on the wall. (In fact, many people went beyond Kovler, and went as far as to email DC police warning them of an incoming siege.) A single Trump tweet had the power to provoke his base into organizing yesterday’s events. "Big protest in D.C. on January 6th. Be there, will be wild!" Trump wrote. “Once Trump said be there,” Kovler said on a phone call Thursday morning, “they interpreted that as a call to action, as their marching orders.” As one Trump supporter on Reddit interpreted it: “DADDY SAYS BE IN DC ON JAN. 6TH.”

Scarier still is how much worse Wednesday could have gone. Kovler wondered if one way the protesters might swing the election in Trump’s favor was by “forcing Congress to certify him as the winner at gunpoint,” he wrote in the original Twitter thread from December. This wasn’t baseless theorizing, either—it, too, came from online posting visible to anyone who bothered to look. “They imagined that this was the day there were going to be mass executions of Congressmen,” Kovler said. So while DC police assert there was “no intelligence that suggests that there would be a breach of the US Capitol,” Kovler is just surprised it wasn’t much worse.

Pennsylvania Republicans refused to sit Dem senator whose election was certified & upheld by courts but will not expel GOP senator who participated in insurrectionist mob https://t.co/uNIHDZtLHl

— Ari Berman (@AriBerman) January 8, 2021

DFRLab/Medium:

Op-Ed: For right-wing extremists, this was a victory

The successful attack on Capitol Hill will fuel years of recruitment and mythologizing for post-Trump extremists

Terrorism is spectacle. As attacks grow more shocking and dramatic, the size of their audience increases accordingly. While most observers are terrified and outraged by such violence, a small minority become inspired enough to plan attacks of their own. This is how extremist movements grow. This is how they seek to bend the world to their will.

Social media has dramatically increased the effectiveness of spectacular acts of terror. In 2014, ISIS militants used the viral executions of two American hostages to declare war on the United States. They were rewarded with an exponential increase in Western media coverage and tens of thousands of recruits from more than 100 countries. In 2019, a New Zealand-based white supremacist livestreamed his murder of 51 Muslim congregants in the city of Christchurch. His actions prompted numerous copycat attacks and a global resurgence of white ethno-nationalism.

Yet the media impact and symbolic power of these attacks are dwarfed by the events of January 6, 2021, during which far-right extremists stormed and occupied the U.S. Capitol at the encouragement of President Trump.

Michael Mann talks with Jeff Goodell about his forthcoming book, “The New Climate War,” what he’s learned from the pandemic, and the future of climate politics https://t.co/EHsM9RXLob pic.twitter.com/G8PYeBo9pb

— Rolling Stone (@RollingStone) January 8, 2021

Politico:

POLITICO-Harvard poll: Public strongly backs Biden's demand for Covid aid

The vast majority of Americans are eager for sweeping legislation that could end the pandemic and rescue the ailing economy.

The poll finds strong backing for Biden's vision of an expansive government effort to combat Covid-19, nearly a year into a pandemic that has killed more than 360,000 in the United States and left millions without jobs. A disappointing labor report on Friday, which showed that the country shed jobs for the first time since the spring, may add new urgency for the vaccination effort and additional stimulus.

“They are overwhelmed with wanting to get Covid under control and wanting to get their economic lives back together,” said Robert Blendon, a health policy and political analysis professor at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, who designed the poll.

Nearly 90 percent of poll respondents ranked passing aid for businesses and individuals hurt by the pandemic's economic effects as “extremely important.” More than eight in 10 expressed the same enthusiasm for federal action expanding access to food stamps and bolstering support for testing and vaccination efforts.

Just so we're clear here... Some GOP denunciation of Trump, but when it came to objecting to AZ/PA electors... A majority of House Republicans did. This was after the storming of the capitol.

— (((Harry Enten))) (@ForecasterEnten) January 8, 2021

Molly Jong-Fast/Daily Beast:

The One Good Thing the MAGA Mobs Smashed? The Trump Kids’ Futures.

For a while, Ivanka and the failsons looked like the future of the GOP. That all changed Wednesday.

The Trump presidency has largely been one four-year-long experiment in failsonness. What happens when a child of privilege who has never worked for anything gets everything? What happens when you make a failson president? And then that failson stocks his administration with other failsons? President failson hired only the best people—like his daughter, who until working at the White House had mostly been designing sweatshop-manufactured plastic shoes, and his son-in-law, who mostly worked for his own father, a felon. One is not born a fail son...well actually, maybe one is.

41% of Trump voters believe he has “betrayed the values and interests of the Republican Party.” 55% say his supporters who invaded the Capitol should be prosecuted for their actions and 29% believe they committed treason. https://t.co/UCffBelVs3

— Jay Van Bavel (@jayvanbavel) January 9, 2021

Olivia Nuzzi/New York:

Senior Trump Official: We Were Wrong, He’s a ‘Fascist’

Advisers have expressed concern and anger over Mark Meadows, the chief of staff, whose actions have been perceived as an effort to secure employment with Trump in his post-presidency, perhaps at the Trump Organization.  “Jared has been telling people, ‘Don’t even deal with him anymore,’” one adviser said. “Mark’s responsible for bringing kook after crazy after conniver after Rudy into the West Wing.” A former senior White House official said, “Morale plummeted under him, huge mistakes were made — and now he’s scrambling to stick around after. He’s a dishonest asshole who pretends to be this religious Southern gentleman. Fuck that.”

The senior administration official put it this way: “The only way it gets to this point are a thousand really bad small decisions. The first time Sidney Powell calls the White House switchboard and is allowed to speak to the president, the next thing you know she and others are in the West Wing — these are areas where the chief of staff has unilateral authority to do what he wants to do.” Instead, the official said, Meadows tells Trump what he wants to hear, and often calls whomever Trump has directed him to call, repeats what Trump told him to say, and then apologizes, explaining that he just needs to be able to tell the boss that he followed his orders.

"Closing the Barn door after the horses have eaten the children." https://t.co/3uREsCFGx7

— David Anaxagoras (@davidanaxagoras) January 8, 2021

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: We all saw it coming. Now resign or be impeached (again).

Facebook and Instagram have banned Donald Trump, and Twitter has frozen his account. Sen Schumer and Speaker Pelosi have called for the 25th Amendment, or failing that, impeachment.

Elaine Chou and Betsy DeVos have resigned (too cowardly to invoke the 25th?). And Donald Trump is sorry as the House moves to impeach.

Welcome to Friday. 

WSJ editorial board:

Donald Trump’s Final Days

The best outcome would be for him to resign to spare the U.S. another impeachment fight.

Adam Davidson/Twitter:

I woke up furious. I have received so much anger from old friends at NPR and the NYT for warning them, telling them, and, yes, sometimes publicly tweeting about how their coverage is normalizing Trump and his followers, legitimizing their lies and downplaying the crisis.  
Yesterday's crisis was created by Trump and his followers. And yesterday showed that many journalists are willing to state that some actions by an elected leader are unacceptable. But they will return to institutional cowardice.

☀️Punchbowl AM — 🚨House Dems are moving rapidly toward impeaching ⁦@realDonaldTrump⁩ again. It will easily pass the House. Pelosi is furious. Question is will Senate Republicans flip. Noon House Dem call today. pic.twitter.com/3TCY0p4Xuq

— Jake Sherman (@JakeSherman) January 8, 2021

“That is the overwhelming sentiment of my caucus,” from her presser yesterday.

Elaine Chao's resignation, and her husband Mitch McConnell's break with Trump bring to mind what Ruth Ben-Ghiat, authoritarian expert, and author of "Strongmen" calls "The phenomenon of elite defection in the end, when their personal safety is in peril."

— Jane Mayer (@JaneMayerNYer) January 7, 2021

WaPo on LARPing (live action role play):

Internet detectives are identifying scores of pro-Trump rioters at the Capitol. Some have already been fired.

As he strolled past gold-framed portraits of past Congressional leaders, one rioter who stormed the Capitol in a pro-Trump mob on Wednesday wore a red Trump hat, a commemorative sweatshirt from the president’s inauguration and a lanyard around his neck.

When a photo of him went viral, it didn’t take Internet sleuths long to realize that the lanyard held his work badge — clearly identifying him as an employee of Navistar Direct Marketing, a printing company in Frederick, Md.

On Thursday, Navistar swiftly fired him.

He’s not alone among the rioters who wreaked havoc in Congress. While police and the FBI work to identify and arrest members of the mob, online detectives are also crowdsourcing information and doxing them — exposing the rioters to criminal prosecution, but also more immediate action from their bosses.

We need to keep saying this: Democracy reform has to be the top priority for 2021. A fascist minority has used our political system to achieve disproportionate influence, powered by zero-sum demonization. This should never happen again.

— Lee Drutman (@leedrutman) January 7, 2021

USA Today editorial:

Invoke the 25th Amendment: Donald Trump forfeited his moral authority to stay in office

Our View: By egging on a deadly insurrection and hailing the rioters, the president's continuance in office poses unacceptable risks to America

This month, time is short, and Trump retains considerable support among congressional Republicans. Shamefully, even after Wednesday’s insurrection, 139 representatives and eight senators backed Trump’s efforts to overturn the will of the voters in Arizona and Pennsylvania.  

That leaves the 25th Amendment, which sets out procedures for replacing an unfit president.  

That sound you hear isn't just Democrats cheering, it's the air going out of tomorrow's GOP clown show in Congress. The Fools on the Hill have picked the wrong cause and bet on the wrong horse. #GASenateRaces #SeditionCaucus

— Larry Sabato (@LarrySabato) January 6, 2021

EE News:

Biden climate team says it underestimated Trump's damage

Some climate moves can't happen until Biden officials remedy those deficiencies, a senior transition official said, because "those have been very carefully directed budget cuts to the very parts of the [EPA] that are going to be necessary to get rid of [Trump's] outrageous rollbacks."

For instance, the official said, EPA's research laboratories have been hollowed out, and its science advisory boards have been depopulated. At the operational level, each of Trump's rollbacks has shuffled the staff and funding that had been in place to carry out regulations.

The EPA workforce has shrunk by more than 600 people since the beginning of Trump's term, another source familiar with the agency review process said.

That's on top of the agency's moves to restrict the kinds of public health research that EPA can use for regulations, and its watering down of the social cost of carbon, the government's metric for analyzing the benefits of emissions cuts.

Joe Scarborough went off on Capitol police live on MSNBC: “You opened the fucking doors for em!” pic.twitter.com/4Ydd4Au8HN

— philip lewis (@Phil_Lewis_) January 7, 2021

NY Times:

Trump Is Said to Have Discussed Pardoning Himself

The discussions occurred in recent weeks, and it was not clear whether he has brought it up since he incited supporters to march on the Capitol, where some stormed the site.

In several conversations since Election Day, Mr. Trump has told advisers that he is considering giving himself a pardon and, in other instances, asked whether he should and what the effect would be on him legally and politically, according to the two people. It was not clear whether he had broached the topic since he incited his supporters on Wednesday to march on the Capitol, where some stormed the building in a mob attack.

Mr. Trump has shown signs that his level of interest in pardoning himself goes beyond idle musings. He has long maintained he has the power to pardon himself, and his polling of aides’ views is typically a sign that he is preparing to follow through on his aims. He has also become increasingly convinced that his perceived enemies will use the levers of law enforcement to target him after he leaves office.

Answer to a q asked by many: It is unclear if acting secretaries count if 25th Amendment is invoked. Best if Pence had a majority of all the Cabinet, incl them, w a majority of confirmed secretaries. Remember, too, Congress can quickly designate another body instead of Cabinet!

— Norman Ornstein (@NormOrnstein) January 7, 2021

KHN:

In Los Angeles and Beyond, Oxygen Is the Latest Covid Bottleneck

It’s gotten so bad that Los Angeles County officials are warning paramedics to conserve it. Some hospitals are having to delay releasing patients as they don’t have enough oxygen equipment to send home with them.

“Everybody is worried about what’s going to happen in the next week or so,” said Cathy Chidester, director of the L.A. County Emergency Medical Services Agency.

The mastermind behind the implementation of the Muslim Ban has thoughts on how he would stand up to Trump now https://t.co/ntQAWAUU0M

— Tim Miller (@Timodc) January 7, 2021

History will not be kind.

Greg Sargent/WaPo:

Democrats are drafting new impeachment articles. Inaction is increasingly untenable.

Some Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee are circulating drafts of new articles of impeachment directed at President Trump for his role in inciting the violent mob assault on the Capitol, a Democratic aide tells me.

It’s unclear whether these will get a vote, or whether they’re intended to pressure members of Trump’s Cabinet to seriously consider removing Trump via the 25th Amendment. Judiciary Committee Democrats have already signed a letter urging Vice President Pence to proceed with that process.

And Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), who will be senate majority leader in the new Congress, has now called for the 25th Amendment to be invoked, adding in a statement: “If the Vice President and the Cabinet refuse to stand up, Congress should reconvene to impeach the president.”

The new articles of impeachment circulating among House Judiciary Democrats argue that Trump committed high crimes and misdemeanors and violated his oath to defend the Constitution and faithfully execute the office of the presidency by inciting Wednesday’s violence.

💯 For those of us who have covered Trump since 2016, it is hard to overstate how utterly inevitable and unsurprising yesterday’s insurrection felt. There was this amazing — disturbing — video we produced of racism and violence at Trump rallies. 👇(1/3) https://t.co/FCUwFmwdmH

— Ashley Parker (@AshleyRParker) January 7, 2021

Max Boot/WaPo:

Mitch McConnell and Kevin McCarthy have led Republicans to disaster. They must go.

In 2016, Never Trumpers predicted that by nominating an ignorant and egomaniacal bigot, the Republican Party would lead the country and itself to ruin.

The consequences have proved far worse than even President Trump’s opponents could have predicted. Who, after all, could have imagined that more than 360,000 Americans would die during Trump’s last year in office because of his catastrophic mismanagement of a pandemic? Or that the U.S. Capitol would be invaded by a mob of Trump supporters?

But the political consequences for the Republican Party have not been as dire as they should have been. Until now.

Trump seems to have surrendered his ferocious effort to hang onto power after Congress formally accepted Biden's victory but the nation’s government remained in disarray following a mob attack on the Capitol that struck at the heart of American democracy. https://t.co/PFfNX4dE8x

— Peter Baker (@peterbakernyt) January 7, 2021

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: A Democracy, If You Can Keep It

“Victory has a thousand fathers, but defeat is an orphan”. - John F Kennedy

Aaron Astor on this NYT “How Joe Biden Won the Presidency” piece:

Good piece of reporting overall. Takeaways:

  1. Biden himself was more important to the campaign's direction than generally thought
  2. Twitter isn't real life
  3. The pandemic "helped" bc it underscored Biden's already-developed "healing" theme
  4. GA>NC>FL

"We won, and it was because of what my folks did" is so much better than "we lost and it's because of what you folks did".

Joe Biden will be the 1st candidate to win 51% of the vote against an incumbent president since... FDR.

— Jesse Lehrich (@JesseLehrich) November 8, 2020

Jonathan Chait/New York:

The End of an Error

This country was always better than Donald Trump.

Trump has been fanatical on the subject of portraying his shocking election in the cloak of an imagined popular mandate. It is why he instructed his press secretary to tell farcical lies about his inaugural crowds, why he has circulated misleading maps showing the vast land areas occupied by his supporters, and why he has depicted his enemies as an elite and alien force. They needed to depict Trump as the true representative of the volk.

In a strange way, liberals needed to believe this, too. The shock of Trump’s election provoked a crisis of self-confidence for his opponents. Humans have an innate need to believe events with profound importance must have profound causes. Trump’s success must reveal some vast and terrible secret. They — Trump’s America — must be, if not more numerous, then at least more authentic, bound together by a secret bond inaccessible to the rest of us. Trump benefitted from polling errors both in 2016 and 2020 that imbued him with a mystical aura, a wizard possessing a secret connection to the heartland that was invisible to the elite.

The simple truth is that was all a mistake — a ghastly, deadly mistake, the toll of which will linger for decades. The precise causes have all been exhumed: bad decisions by Hillary Clinton, an easily manipulated press corps, the FBI, the GRU, the Electoral College sorting out the votes just so.

Sunday night update on Biden's leads: GA: 10K AZ: 17K NV: 34K PA: 43K His lead over Trump nationally is over 4.4 million and rising. If states had all counted their mail-in ballots early, this election would've been called Tuesday night and wouldn't be seen as all that close.

— Josh Jordan (@NumbersMuncher) November 9, 2020

More from Aaron:

I keep coming back to how hard it is to unseat an incumbent President. Ultimately it was Trump himself who flubbed the Presidency away. Each misstep added up. Not one single incident - a bunch of failures on pandemic and Floyd protests pushed enough non-Twitter people away.
 
There absolutely was a reservoir of support for Trump that could have carried him over the top - every incumbent carries it (think of Ford nearly winning 1976; W in 2004 & Obama 2012 each beating their poll numbers in the end). So Biden had to take advantage of each Trump error. 
This is especially true for a challenger running on a "restoration" campaign and not on a "new direction" theme. It would be more important to get all anti-Trump voters to vote than to create whole new groups of supporters who might flake out in the end. JOMD helped on that end. 

We were fighting demagoguery, thuggery, and authoritarianism. Where were you? https://t.co/lmkG3hgZ6P

— Bill Kristol (@BillKristol) November 8, 2020

Politico:

‘This f---ing virus’: Inside Donald Trump’s 2020 undoing

How Biden prevailed and Trump fell short in an unforgettable election, according to conversations with 75 insiders.

Trump was perplexed. The economy was strong. The president had built an enormous political infrastructure and was raking in hundreds of millions of dollars. That month, Trump’s campaign conducted a $1.1 million polling project showing him leading prospective Democratic challengers even in blue states such as Colorado, New Mexico, and New Hampshire.

“Sir, regardless, this is coming. It’s the only thing that could take down your presidency,” Parscale told the president.

Trump snapped.

“This fucking virus,” Trump asked dismissively, according to a person with direct knowledge of the exchange, “what does it have to do with me getting reelected?”

That was exactly the attitude Joe Biden expected from the president. And Biden saw his task as unambiguous.

Create a contrast. Follow the scientists whom Trump ignored. Wear a mask, halt public events and reinvent campaigning to avoid putting people in harm’s way.

I could write jokes for 800 years and I'd never think of something funnier than Trump booking the Four Seasons for his big presser, and it turning out to be the Four Seasons Total Landscaping parking lot between a dildo store and a crematorium. pic.twitter.com/P45HV1daD9

— Zack Bornstein (@ZackBornstein) November 8, 2020

Daily Beast:

As the nation is in a fit of laughter that may never stop over the Trump campaign press conference that was, through a hot potato game of incompetence, held not at Philadelphia’s swank Four Seasons hotel but at the Four Seasons Total Landscaping company’s parking lot next to a porn shop, it was only fitting that Kate McKinnon’s Rudy Giuliani made a stop at the Saturday Night Live “Weekend Update” desk.

“Did you see my press conference today?” McKinnon’s Giuliani greeted Update co-anchor Colin Jost. “It was at the Four Seasons. Fancy!”

“I’m glad I made it to the show on time,” he continued. “First I went to 30 Rocks. That’s a granite quarry in New Rochelle.”

Four Seasons Total Landscaping, near the adult book store, across from the cremation center. Got it.

— Jake Tapper (@jaketapper) November 8, 2020

History is going to be absolutely brutal on some of these people.

— Tim Alberta (@TimAlberta) November 6, 2020

Garry Kasparov/NY Daily News:

The damage Donald’s done: How Trump’s ongoing tantrum against democracy hurts America

The election is over at last, called decisively for Joe Biden after four days of extreme care and caution in the democratic process. Unsurprisingly, the sitting president’s response is to attack that process with baseless accusations. For someone who talks so much about law and order, Donald Trump never wants it to apply to him. He cares little for what is legal and not at all about what is right.

I have spent much of my life at the chessboard taking the measure of people under tremendous stress while trying to manage my own. When we’re under pressure, we show our true colors. Sometimes we rise to the challenge to find character and resources we didn’t know we had. Or we collapse, unable to deal with the rush of emotions as the clock ticks down.

With time ticking away on his presidency on Thursday night, Trump cracked under the pressure. He’d managed to keep quiet for two days as the returns slowly came in, but as the results in key states tipped toward a Biden victory, he could control himself no longer and took to the podium.

What followed was Trump reduced to his purest self, a lying, self-centered bully who has finally been punched in the nose. The result was called “the most dishonest speech of his presidency” by CNN expert Daniel Dale, no small achievement.

While the margin was not what pre-election polls suggested, statistically it is quite the achievement for Biden. He beat a 20+ person primary field. Came back after losing IA+NH+NV. And then became the 1st man to defeat a sitting president since 1992.

— (((Harry Enten))) (@ForecasterEnten) November 7, 2020

Daily Beast:

WATCH: Cheering, Honking Erupts Moment Biden is Declared Winner

As Joe Biden was declared the 46th president at 11:30 a.m. ET Saturday, the sound of cheering, horns honking and champagne bottles popping broke out in streets across the county.

I’ve lived in NYC my whole life and I’ve never seen anything like this pic.twitter.com/KVZakF7F5n

— Jessica Valenti (@JessicaValenti) November 7, 2020

It wasn’t just the general elation, it was celebrating the new heroes, the USPS:

Okay this one got me 😭 pic.twitter.com/C0Cghj984f

— 🦛 Peter Koltak 🦛 (@PeterKoltak) November 7, 2020

That happened every time a postal truck drove by.

Everyone in Manhattan going absolutely apeshit every time a USPS truck drives by is the exact energy I need today pic.twitter.com/adFlsCkr08

— your idiot friend (@dcousineau) November 7, 2020

A lot of Tim Alberta today for his excellent sources:

The Election That Broke the Republican Party

By lashing themselves to the president’s desperate conspiracies of fraud, GOP officials have undermined their own legitimacy.

Never has the unprecedented been so utterly predictable.

At the conclusion of a campaign that exceeded their expectations in almost every sense — picking up House seats, thwarting an outright Democratic takeover of the Senate, running competitively in every presidential battleground state — Republicans could have walked away from 2020 with some dignity intact. They could have conceded defeat to Joe Biden, celebrated their hard-fought successes elsewhere and braced for the battles ahead

But that was never going to happen. This is Donald Trump’s party — at least, for another 76 days — and no Republican who hopes to remain relevant after he’s gone was going to deny him the bloody farewell he’s been building toward.

Did we really think the president worked so diligently these past eight months to create an environment conducive to allegations of mass voter fraud, only to stop short of alleging mass voter fraud? Of course not. Even if the president had been swept in every swing state, and by big margins, he was always going to cry foul. That he lost such close contests — and lost them in a style so unfamiliar to so many voters — only made his reaction all the more inevitable.

This might seem like a small thing, but I just saw a stat that in Georgia’s 7th district (which includes big Asian suburbs like Duluth), 41% of Asian American voters were first-time voters. That’s huge! Add that to the celebration of the amazing work that happened in GA ✨

— abolition is possible! ~franny (@fannychoir) November 7, 2020

The Bulwark:

Those Obama-Trump Counties

What it means that the president held most of them.

Since Trump’s victory in 2016, some Democrats have concluded that the relationship is not worth repairing since these former blue strongholds are simply the home to racist deplorables. That has been a mistake. As we argue in our new book, Trump’s Democrats, citizens in these communities admire Trump not primarily because of defects in their personal character. Rather, they like Trump for reasons that are more cultural than psychological.

After living in three blue strongholds that flipped in 2016, we found that many were Trumpy well before Trump arrived on the national political stage. Some of these communities’ most beloved Democratic leaders are brazen, thin-skinned, nepotistic, and promise to provide for their constituents by cutting deals—and corners, if needed. This is partly because their political culture has been shaped by a working-class honor culture that prizes strong men and a tradition of boss-style politics that is more transactional than ideological.

These citizens also have strong loyalties to hometowns that are confronting serious social and economic problems. Unlike the Proud Boys, most Trump Democrats take more pride in their hometown than their skin color. And while the extent of Trump’s success among black and Latino voters this week won’t be understood until the exit polls have been reweighted—and maybe not even then—just looking at some of the places where he performed well at the polls suggests that his appeal cannot be reduced to white nationalism.

You want to know how much the Navajo Nation dislikes trump? 1. of the 85,000 registered voters on Navajo 76,000 voted. 89% turn out 2. Of those 76,000 voters 74,000 voted for Biden & 2,000 for Trump 3. Biden’s current lead in Arizona sits at about 40,000 Ya’ah’teeh MFs

— Len Necefer, Ph.D. (@lennecefer) November 7, 2020

Kristine Phillips and Kevin Johnson/USA Today:

'Vulnerable to prosecution': When Trump leaves White House, presidential 'cloak of immunity' goes away

"The short answer is that once he leaves the office, his cloak of immunity, actual or implied by (Justice Department guidelines), will disappear," said David Weinstein, a former Florida federal prosecutor.

The Justice Department has a long-standing policy that a sitting president cannot be prosecuted for criminal offenses. Former special counsel Robert Mueller cited the policy when investigators elected not to make a determination on whether Trump obstructed justice during the investigation into Russia's interference in the 2016 election.

But that immunity is for actions he took while in office, and "it stops there," Weinstein said.

The most significant threats against Trump once he leaves office are brewing in his hometown, New York City.  

That means no presidential pardon.

A man wearing a Puerto Rican flag tosses paper towel over the fence toward the White House. “Never forget,” he said. pic.twitter.com/tZkalqgB2D

— Samantha Schmidt (@schmidtsam7) November 7, 2020

More work to do:

@DemFromCT Please see the garbage coming out of the NE govs office in response to a respectful organized social media campaign by docs begging for help as the pandemic rages here. Notably, he singles out only the female docs. Despicable. Please don’t let this go unnoticed. https://t.co/NHvPfWkH1r

— Fearless Girl (@FearlessGirl33) November 8, 2020

📍False characterization. We *are out here saying to people to celebrate at a distance and wear masks. Outdoors=better. Masks=better. Much more distance=best. Hotels, bars, + indoor restaurants are big problems. It’s why Floyd protests didn’t cause big spikes but Sturgis did. https://t.co/MVULPV5C2m

— Jeremy Faust MD MS (ER physician) (@jeremyfaust) November 8, 2020

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: A simple election, a simple choice. Three more days to make it.

AP:

Election emerges as referendum on race relations in America

Omari Barksdale, a Black man, watched with alarm as the toll of the country’s racial injustice mounted. People of color bore the brunt of pandemic-related job losses. Police shot and killed Breonna Taylor inside her Kentucky home, and a Minneapolis police officer pressed a knee into George Floyd’s neck for nearly eight minutes as Floyd gasped, “I can’t breathe,” in his final moments.

The convergence of the pandemic, joblessness and police brutality has forced the U.S. to confront its centuries-old legacy of systemic racism this year. And for Barksdale and many Black Americans, it’s turned next week’s presidential election into a referendum on the future of race relations, an opportunity to take steps toward healing or the potential of a deeper divide.

In some ways this race is simple. Most voters like Biden. Most voters don't like Trump. https://t.co/XpCDpfJ1u1

— Philip Bump (@pbump) October 30, 2020

Amazing. Youth vote in Texas up more than 600 percent. https://t.co/d7WQmwmYH7

— Vanita Gupta (@vanitaguptaCR) October 30, 2020

Charlie Cook/National Journal:

Don't expect a contested election

The cone of uncertainty has narrowed considerably. Now, the question seems to be whether we'll see a "skinny" Biden win or a landslide.

The RealClearPolitics average of national polls pegs Biden’s lead at 7.4 points, 51.1 to 43.7 percent. But that’s a less discriminating measure, including as it does some mediocre surveys, some that seemed congenitally slanted toward one side or the other, and some that would be better utilized lining hamster cages. The FiveThirtyEight modeled average of national polls, which is more selective than the RCP average but still includes some surveys that I consider rather sketchy, puts the Biden lead at 8.8 points, 52 to 43.2 percent.

I believe his actual lead is more like 9 or 10 points, based on the higher-quality, live-telephone-interview national polls conducted since the first debate, as well as the gold standard of online polling, the Pew Research Center’s mammoth poll of 11,929 voters released two weeks ago.

Any way you slice it, these are pretty good leads, considerably higher than the 3.2-point national margin that Hillary Clinton had over Trump in the RCP average on Oct. 29, 2016. When all the votes were counted, the margin ended up being 2.1 percent.

The narrow margins could also cause the networks/cable channels to take longer than usual to call the solid Republican states, instead of doing them just after poll closing.

— Nathan Gonzales (@nathanlgonzales) October 30, 2020

Ryan Matsumoto/The Hill:

Why Biden could actually win Texas

The biggest political realignment of the 2016 election was a shift based on education. Trump made big gains with white voters without a college degree, allowing him to crack the “Blue Wall” and win Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania. The flipside, however, was that Clinton made big gains with white voters with a college degree, especially in Sun Belt states where they had historically been pretty Republican.

In Texas, this political tradeoff was a net negative for Republicans. Although Trump won Texas by 9 points in 2016, this was a substantial underperformance compared to Mitt Romney’s 16-point margin in 2012, John McCain’s 12-point margin in 2008, and George W. Bush’s 23-point margin in 2004.

In Texas, the counties with the highest percentage of college graduates are large suburban counties in the major metropolitan areas (Dallas-Fort Worth, Houston, Austin, and San Antonio). One key example is Collin County, which includes the upscale northern Dallas suburbs of Plano, McKinney, and Frisco. After voting for Romney by 32 points in 2012, it voted for Trump by 17 points in 2016. Two years later, Republican Sen. Ted Cruz only carried the county by 6 points in his re-election bid against Democrat Beto O’Rourke.

In our polls the second half of this week we've been pretty consistently finding (modest) late movement toward Biden rather than the other way around

— PublicPolicyPolling (@ppppolls) October 30, 2020

President (Florida) Biden (D) 52% Trump (R) 45% 10/28-10/29 by Public Policy Polling (B) 941 V NOTE: partisan (D) poll Woof woof! Can I have a treat? Poll #135692 #ElectionTwitter

— Stella 2020 (@stella2020woof) October 30, 2020

Amelia Thomson-DeVeaux/FiveThirtyEight:

Trump Is Losing Ground With Some — But Not All — White Christians

So is Biden’s plan working? Are white Christians, including white evangelical Protestants, who have been among Trump’s most loyal supporters, actually abandoning the president for Biden?

The answer depends on which white Christians you’re looking at.

Despite Biden’s claims that he can appeal to white evangelical Protestants, there really aren’t any signs that Trump is losing support among this group. But Trump may have reason to worry about his level of support among white Catholics. Politicians and the media typically pay less attention to these voters during election season, but white Catholics are especially important to watch this year because they’re a sizable group — and they’re concentrated in Rust Belt swing states like Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania.

Trump won white Catholics handily in 2016, but there are signs that his hold on this group is slipping. That’s doubly worrisome for the president because white Christians are declining as a share of the population overall. And if overall turnout is high and he loses some support from white Catholics without making up the difference among other groups, Trump could be in trouble — even if he overwhelmingly wins white evangelicals again.

NBC-Marist poll: North Carolina president: Likely voters Joe Biden 52% Donald Trump 46% North Carolina Senate: Likely voters Cal Cunningham (D) 53% Thom Tillis (R) 43%

— Kyle Griffin (@kylegriffin1) October 30, 2020

USA Today:

Poll: Most Americans disapprove of Trump's decision to hold massive campaign rallies during COVID-19 pandemic

It's the most stark stylistic difference between President Donald Trump and Joe Biden: The incumbent has surrounded himself with thousands of supporters at dozens of rallies while the Democratic challenger is literally keeping his distance.

But as Trump and Biden embrace strikingly different approaches to campaigning during the coronavirus pandemic, a new USA TODAY/Suffolk University poll finds that nearly two-thirds of likely voters prefer Biden’s low-key strategy to Trump's raucous fanfare.

Nearly six in 10 Americans disapprove of Trump's decision to continue to hold large rallies during the pandemic, according to the poll, while nearly 64% approve of Biden's decision to jettison big events in favor of much smaller gatherings.

This was a fairly weird day for polling with a lot of volume but relatively few high-prestige polls ... but it's hard to find anything much with a favorable trendline for Trump. https://t.co/9AeTKX5o0O

— Nate Silver (@NateSilver538) October 30, 2020

Tom Nichols/USA Today:

Why this conservative voted for Biden and you should too: Trump is a morally defective man

I'm a conservative and former Republican who did not vote based on policy. Neither should you. The 2020 election is about the moral future of America.

Don’t get me wrong: As a conservative and former Republican who has already voted for former Vice President Joe Biden, I could create an entire inventory of issues, even without the lightning strike of the pandemic, where I think Biden is a better pick for president than another four years of President Donald Trump. From budget deficits to nuclear arms control, I could easily make the case for Biden, even if I might concede that I would prefer a few of Trump’s policies (such as cutting government regulations and increasing defense spending) over any Democratic administration.

But I did not vote in this election based on policy. Neither should you. The election of 2020 is about the moral future of the American nation, and so I voted for a good man with whom I have some political disagreements over an evil man with whom I share not a single value as a human being. Trump is the most morally defective human being ever to hold the office of the presidency, worse by every measure than any of the rascals, satyrs or racists who have sat in the Oval Office. This is vastly more important than marginal tax rates or federal judges.

Battleground polling of all voters - white, Black, Latino found the child separation issue badly hurts Trump. Because it was immoral and unethical. https://t.co/MB6wZitu8B

— Matt A. Barreto 🇵🇪 ⚽️ (@realMABarreto) October 29, 2020

Will Bunch/Philly.com:

Trump’s politicized Supreme Court has lost legitimacy. 2021’s Dems, do something!

We don’t yet know what will happen after Tuesday when the voting stops and the serious counting starts, nor is the Supreme Court’s role in determining the final outcome cast in stone — as dramatized later in the week when Kavanaugh again surprised the legal scholars by shifting gears and siding with the court’s remaining liberals to not — for now — limit the vote counting here in Pennsylvania or North Carolina, two other key states.

But even before the election is decided, we’ve already seen enough to know that Republicans have essentially politicized the nation’s highest court to a level where the judiciary can no longer be expected to fulfill its primary constitutional function, to serve as a balance and to check any abuses of power by the other two branches, the presidency and Congress. The faint echoes were there when five GOP-appointed justices twisted legal logic to halt the 2000 vote counting and declare George W. Bush the 43rd president, then ratcheted up to a volume of 11 when democracy-hating Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell used brute authoritarian logic to steal Supreme Court seats on either end of the Trump presidency. That’s all been against a drumbeat of rulings that have enhanced a warped notion called “corporate personhood,” while empowering billionaire donors and making it harder for historically oppressed people to vote.

All of this is causing policy wonks, including a handful of thinkers on Capitol Hill, to ask if it’s time for a radical overhaul of a court whose size and exact mission weren’t really spelled out when the Constitution was drafted in 1787.

There were a lot of people who told me not to bother with a persuasion strategy targeted at (what I saw as) a margin of gettable Republicans and right-leaning Indy’s. “We’re too polarized,” they said. I think it was worth bothering. Victory is in the margins. @RVAT2020 https://t.co/a35G5J5JWi

— Sarah Longwell (@SarahLongwell25) October 30, 2020

Persuasion for the win.

See, this is why you can't infer much about how early voting from party alone. In Florida, Ds currently have only a 2-point edge (D 40/R 38/I 22) in early + absentee voting. But if the partisan splits are as below, it would translate to Biden being ahead 56-39 with those voters. https://t.co/IYMfdmwD2A

— Nate Silver (@NateSilver538) October 30, 2020

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: 10 days to go. Eye on the prize.

WaPo:

America is poised to enter into its worst stretch yet of the pandemic

The nation nears a record-breaking daily number of coronavirus cases.

The current surge is already considerably more widespread than the waves from last summer and spring. On Thursday, the number of cases topped 70,000 for the first time since July.

The unprecedented geographic spread of the current surge makes it especially dangerous, with experts warning it could lead to dire shortages of medical staff and supplies. Already, hospitals are reporting shortfalls of basic drugs needed to treat covid-19, the disease caused by the novel coronavirus.

And it’s not simply a matter of increased testing identifying more cases. Covid-19 hospitalizations increased in 38 states over the past week and are rising so quickly that many facilities in the West and Midwest are already overwhelmed. The number of deaths nationally has crested above 1,000 in recent days.

Further indication that voters may be starting to tune out the Trump show. https://t.co/ffFDxNlHHO

— David Lauter (@DavidLauter) October 23, 2020

FiveThirtyEight:

Who Won The Last Presidential Debate?

We partnered with Ipsos to poll voters before and after the candidates took the stage.

Most respondents went into the debate with a clear candidate preference, and that didn’t really change. The debate also didn’t have much of an effect on who respondents thought would win the presidency, although fewer people said the race was a toss-up (14 percent, compared to 16 percent before the debate). The share who thought Biden had a better chance of winning increased from 43 percent to 46 percent, though both those changes are well within the poll’s margin of error.

Lots of data now to suggest youth vote highly motivated this election. Using @TargetSmart's TargetEarly data 18-29 y/o share of early vote up 31% from 2016, a remarkable thing. Youth much bigger slice of a much larger early vote pie. Not sure many saw that coming. (Thread)

— Simon Rosenberg (@SimonWDC) October 23, 2020

Upshot:

Not the huge win Trump needed. 

For Mr. Trump, even a draw would have been a blow to his chances. He trails by nearly 10 percentage points in national surveys, and although he still has a chance in the most crucial battleground states, like Florida and Pennsylvania, his path to an Electoral College victory remains narrow. With just 11 days to go, there aren’t many obvious opportunities remaining for him to change the attitudes of voters.

Maybe the post-debate coverage will focus on something that could help the president in certain battleground areas, like Mr. Biden’s comments about transitioning away from the oil industry. But the president had his own potentially damaging comments, such as his reaction to separating children from their parents at the border. Maybe there will be another big news event over the final stretch. (It was at this point in the 2016 campaign — with 11 days to go — that the F.B.I. director James Comey sent a letter to Congress about new evidence in the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s emails.) Or maybe things will just naturally tighten on their own, which happened after the third debate in 2016, even before the Comey letter and even though Mrs. Clinton won the post-debate instant polls after the final debate.

But if the polls do not tighten significantly over the final stretch, Mr. Trump will be left in an unenviable position. He will once again be left to hope for a large, systematic error in the polling, this time dwarfing the one that barely got him to victory four years ago in a much closer race.

Here's why this case is so important: https://t.co/dkTynJ4IKF Voting experts think the vast majority of ballots rejected for signature mismatch are actually valid. https://t.co/bjHZUkiYH5

— David A. Graham (@GrahamDavidA) October 23, 2020

Scott Detrow:

Hi. It me, the campaign reporter who also spent several years literally only reporting on Pennsylvania and fracking. There are a LOT of things us national reporters are oversimplifying and dumbing down here. Hold onto your butts for a thread. 
-Fracking – more accurately the energy economy that has sprung up around it -- has been a real boost to the state, particularly Western Pa. Pittsburgh has become a Houstoneque energy hub. 
-It’s always been controversial and many Pennsylvanians have been skeptical – particularly in the vote-rich eastern half of the state. And as both Dem and GOP governors under-regulated, voters wanted more scrutiny. 

"If you want to know why the GOP sued in Clark over mail ballots: The Dems lead 108,000 to 38,000."https://t.co/9De3fV0Pjt

— Greg Dworkin (@DemFromCT) October 23, 2020

UPDATE: Judge denies temporary restraining order request by Trump campaign, Nevada Republicans to stop Clark County mail vote countinghttps://t.co/X9DeNNS1qw

— Nevada Independent (@TheNVIndy) October 23, 2020

David Rothkopf and Bernard Schwartz/Daily Beast:

Never Forget the Particulars of Trump’s Epic Homestretch Meltdown

From calling fallen soldiers ‘suckers’ to refusing to commit to transfer of power, he’s run the strangest, weakest, and most un-American campaign in history.

Forget Russiagate. Forget the Muslim ban. Forget Charlottesville. Forget Hurricane Maria. Forget attacking our allies and embracing dictators. Forget gutting environmental protections. Forget children in cages. Forget Putin in Helsinki. Forget the racism and the sexism, the stories of abuse and of tax fraud. Forget the obstruction of justice and the impeachment. Forget even the failure of leadership that initially caused the COVID crisis and its economic aftershocks.

In fact, forget the first 44 months of the Trump presidency. Bad as they were, the worst in the history of the American presidency, you don’t need them to make the case that Trump must be defeated on November 3. Just focus on the last few weeks, Trump’s meltdown in the homestretch of the campaign.

Dems are deluding themselves if they think rural white voters aren’t going to turn out. It’ll be through the roof. To me, the biggest remaining question mark is rural *nonwhite* turnout - esp. in FL/GA/NC/TX.

— Dave Wasserman (@Redistrict) October 23, 2020

Alexander C Kaufman/HuffPost:

At Last, Joe Biden Leaned Into Climate

Polls overwhelmingly show President Trump’s climate denial is his greatest weakness. At the final debate, the Democrat seized on the issue.

Joe Biden finally turned up the heat on climate change.

At his final presidential debate Thursday night, the Democratic nominee leaned into the issue on which polls show he’s most handily outmatching President Donald Trump, a fossil fuel hard-liner who has stubbornly clung to conspiracies and pseudoscience in the face of mounting climate disasters.

“Global warming is an existential threat to humanity,” Biden said. “We have a moral obligation to deal with it.”

Trump wants to recreate the Hillary-email magic with Hunter's "laptop from hell." Here's why it isn't working. https://t.co/qZfIjvTLEH

— Jonathan Chait (@jonathanchait) October 23, 2020

Adam Serwer/Atlantic:

The Supreme Court Is Helping Republicans Rig Elections

Adding more justices to the bench might be the only way to stop them.

For a judge with a brilliant legal mind, Amy Coney Barrett seemed oddly at a loss for words.

Does a president have the power to postpone an election? Senator Dianne Feinstein of California asked. Barrett said she would have to approach that question—about a power the Constitution explicitly grants to Congress—“with an open mind.”

Is voter intimidation illegal? Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota asked. “I can’t apply the law to a hypothetical set of facts,” Barrett replied. Klobuchar responded by reading the statute outlawing voter intimidation, which exists and is, therefore, not hypothetical.

Should the president commit to a peaceful transfer of power? Senator Cory Booker of New Jersey asked. Barrett replied that, “to the extent this is a political controversy right now, as a judge I want to stay out of it.”

always the most racist person in the room https://t.co/1xYe4Mtf8Z

— darth™ (@darth) October 23, 2020

Ryan Lizza/Politico:

Trump's sideshow fizzles out

The president tried to turn debate day into a trial of the Biden family's allegedly shady business dealings. It didn't go smoothly.

In the end, the Nashville debate was more about Tony Fauci than Tony Bobulinski.

Trailing by nearly 10 points in the polls, and facing the potential for the greatest repudiation of an incumbent president since Jimmy Carter in 1980 — a 400-plus electoral vote victory is possible for Joe Biden — Donald Trump arrived at the final debate of the 2020 campaign seized by an issue that was never really discussed.

“We’re not entering a dark winter. We’re entering the final turn and approaching the light at the end of the tunnel” — Trump on Covid just now, hoping that merely repeating the same optimism for eight-plus months can distort reality

— Sam Stein (@samstein) October 23, 2020

Berkman Klein Center:

Partisanship, Impeachment, and the Democratic Primaries: American Political Discourse

PUBLIC DISCOURSE IN THE U.S. 2020 ELECTION: JANUARY AND FEBRUARY

The biggest change we observe in these first two months of 2020 compared to the election cycle of four years ago is the degree to which conservative media activists have shaped mainstream media coverage. In 2016, right-wing media activists succeeded in influencing mainstream coverage of Hillary Clinton, particularly on the unsubstantiated allegations of wrongdoing associated with the Clinton Foundation, which exacerbated and fed upon coverage of her emails and fueled suspicions of corruption and dishonesty. In the current election cycle, conservative media activists rolled out the same playbook that was so successful in 2016. This time, the corruption allegations were focused on Joe Biden, his son Hunter, and their dealings with Ukraine and China. This story was picked up by mainstream media in 2019, but the core allegation—that Joe Biden pressured Ukraine to remove a prosecutor in order to protect his son—fell apart under scrutiny. By January 2020, while conservative media continued to push out exaggerated and false claims, the dominant mainstream framing of this story had shifted to Donald Trump’s abuse of his presidential power for his own political gain, which overshadowed the well-established and misguided actions of Hunter Biden to cash in on his father’s name. The discredited allegations of corrupt dealings by Joe Biden were getting no play in mainstream media. While conservative media continues to exhibit a remarkable capacity for reframing news coverage to align with the beliefs and perceptions of its core audiences, in January and February of 2020, its power to shape mainstream media coverage was diminished compared to 2016. This is the most notable change we observe and has the potential to alter the electoral calculus in the November election.      

A new @nature paper providing even more evidence that masks really do reduce the spread of #COVID19 . https://t.co/EkcHDQSWBJ

— Kimberly Prather, Ph.D. (@kprather88) October 23, 2020

John A Stoehr/Substack:

Trump holds everyone in contempt, including Republican voters

Scorn for real people's real problems is why the debates matter.

Again, I don’t know exactly what about the first debate caused Biden’s margin over the president to grow. No one can really say for sure. Cause-and-effect is not possible to identify in public polling. But the margin did widen. That’s a fact. Trump’s disdain for ordinary human frailty was a part of that. I can’t help thinking (hoping?) even hard-shelled Republican supporters were put off by the sight of such naked disgust for a problem lots and lots of people face, especially amid the scourge of opioid addiction.

The pundit corps was, last night, and is, this morning, noting the differences between the first and second debate, in particular the president did not beclown himself quite so heroically, which, by the magic of punditry, means he did just as well as Biden. Meanwhile, the concrete detail I’m seeing popping up is Trump’s indifference to the suffering of 500-some children in government custody after being taken from their immigrant parents as part of the administration’s sadistic policy of deterrence. Such indifference is appalling—to liberals and others who have living, beating hearts. But I don’t think Trump’s remarks, however soulless they in fact are, are going to move public polling. (Some apparently believe Trump said “good” in response to the fact that these children are still not reunited with their parents. He didn’t. He said “go ahead” to moderator Kristen Welker. Rendered in mush-mouth, it sounded like “good.”)

Reagan actually extended his lead over the last 11 days in both 1980 and 1984. Carter's margin in '76, Bush's margin in 2004 and Obama's margin in 2008 stayed about the same. In the other 6 elections (6 of the last 9), the frontrunner lost between 3-6 pts over the homestretch. https://t.co/sxJCgQ18Zz

— James Surowiecki (@JamesSurowiecki) October 23, 2020

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: Trump’s assault on democracy likely to anger voters

Donald Trump is losing, and any bad news for him doesn’t help him win. As with most Tuesday night events, the Wednesday morning roundup is a few hours too soon for pundits to really weigh in. But you all get to comment!!

Hmmm. That looks like the regular polls!!!!!! This CBS  instapoll is different than the story of the focus group.

Politico:

Undecided voters call Trump ‘unhinged’ and ‘un-American’ — but unswayed by debate

Snapshots from a Frank Luntz focus group.

Despite their indecisiveness, most described Trump in a negative light, including one of the participants who was leaning toward voting for the president. The voters characterized Trump as “unhinged,” “arrogant,” “forceful”, a “bully,” “chaotic” and “un-American.”

When asked to describe Biden they offered: “better than expected,” “politician,” “compassion,” “coherent,” and a “nice guy lacking vision.”

So, Susan Collins, did Trump learn his lesson from impeachment? No he did not. That’s why you and your fellow Republican enablers need to go. And that’s why the Republicans are losing, and losing badly.

I just don’t think it was a dumpster fire or shit show. It was a frontal assault on our political system.

— Sam Stein (@samstein) September 30, 2020

Bob Woodward called it “assassinating the presidency” this am. And that’s what that was.

The President again last night signaled that the Proud Boys should “stand by” for Election Day. Mobilization to violence is the #1 threat in Election 2020. https://t.co/dizEtACKYc pic.twitter.com/0Idzpchynt

— Clint Watts (@selectedwisdom) September 30, 2020

Biden’s strategy:

Biden campaign thinks calling out Trump for trying to steal the election is counterproductive. Biden instead repeatedly told viewers that their votes would count & that Trump couldn’t stop/change the result. They may be right that it’s more likely to deter turnout than persuade

— Matt Grossmann (@MattGrossmann) September 30, 2020

David Mastio and Jill Lawrence/USA Today:

Trump-Biden presidential debate in Cleveland: Once is enough. Please make it stop.

Joe Biden delivered two messages: He's not senile and he will return America to normal. Enuf said.

The Commission on Presidential Debates should cancel the second and third debates scheduled for President Donald Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden. To hold them would be sadistic. Americans don’t deserve this. Biden didn’t deserve it and neither did the moderator, Chris Wallace.

Trump is uncontrollable and cruel and unpatriotic. He made clear in his closing argument that any election he doesn’t win is rigged and fraudulent. His claims had no basis but may have been enough to scare some people off voting in what used to be the world’s exemplary democracy.

We’ll wait on more comment, though the national outlets will have plenty as the day goes on.  We don’t need another debate.

No hyperbole: The incumbent’s behavior this evening is the lowest moment in the history of the presidency since Andrew Johnson’s racist state papers.

— Jon Meacham (@jmeacham) September 30, 2020

What follows is a more normal content lineup.

WaPo:

Early surge of Democratic mail voting sparks worry inside GOP

Of the more than 9 million voters who requested mail ballots through Monday in Florida, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Maine and Iowa, the five battleground states where such data is publicly available, 52 percent were Democrats. Twenty-eight percent were Republicans, and 20 percent were unaffiliated…

Even more alarming to some Republicans, Democrats are also returning their ballots at higher rates than GOP voters in two of those states where that information is available: Florida and North Carolina...

The margins are “stunning” — and bad news for Republicans up and down the ballot, said longtime GOP pollster Whit Ayres. While the Republican Party is focused on getting voters out on Election Day, he noted that older voters who have traditionally supported Republicans are most concerned about being infected with the novel coronavirus and could choose to stay home if the outbreak intensifies as the election near

People love it when Trump talks over people and makes insults, it's why he's up 7 points in polls.

— Dave Weigel (@daveweigel) September 30, 2020

“Will you shut up, man” is the line of the night 😂😂

— Jill Filipovic (@JillFilipovic) September 30, 2020

You have no idea.

— Hillary Clinton (@HillaryClinton) September 30, 2020

Oh, yeah. 

Just pay your child support and tell your boss to pay his taxes. https://t.co/uetuimIfpy

— Rep. Eric Swalwell (@RepSwalwell) September 29, 2020

Solid moment for Biden, who gets an uninterrupted monologue: "He wouldn’t know a suburb unless he took a wrong turn ... "

— Greg Bluestein (@bluestein) September 30, 2020

Here's the thing: the really hardcore Trump supporters don't understand that he's losing. They live in a disinfo bubble and have no clue. (I've spoken to a couple in person and they think he'll win like 48 states). Weird situation.

— Tom Watson (@tomwatson) September 29, 2020

Ok, that was the debate. Trump did a great job of reinforcing his negatives.

Meanwhile, when Frank asks everyone to associate a word or phrase with Biden, the vast majority are positive in nature.... and several people say Biden was much sharper than they expected him to be, exceeded expectations, etc (brilliant work by Team Trump w/ the senile strategy)

— Tim Alberta (@TimAlberta) September 30, 2020

Dave Catanese/McClatchy:

We’ll stop the bleeding’: Democrats spot erosion of Trump’s rural dominance

Terri Mitko is sure there are former supporters of President Donald Trump who aren’t going to be voting for him again, because she lives with one: Her husband.

“There was a whole ‘I don’t want to vote for Hillary’ contingent. And Hillary’s not running this time,” says Mitko, an attorney and chairwoman of the Beaver County Democratic Party. “Trump was a breath of fresh air and had this schtick going about draining the swamp. ... Well, now we’re onto him.”

Why did the president knowingly mislead America about the coronavirus threat?

— Kyle Griffin (@kylegriffin1) September 29, 2020

Nate Cohn/NY Times:

Biden leads by enough to withstand a polling misfire.New Pennsylvania polls give Biden a significant lead.

For the first time since we started our poll tracker several weeks ago, Joe Biden leads by enough to withstand a repeat of the polling error in 2016.

More than 100,000 votes have already been cast in Minnesota. Based on modeled party ID, Dems account for 46% of all votes cast, 29% GOP, 25% Ind. Dems have a 26% lead among voters who didn't cast a ballot in '16. 45% of these Dems are under the age of 35.

— Tom Bonier (@tbonier) September 29, 2020

Morning Consult:

Biden Carries Post-DNC Image Boost Into the First Presidential Debate

Compared to President Trump, voters more likely to say Biden is compassionate, capable, stable and honest

  • Joe Biden’s favorability (now 50%) has been above water among likely voters since the Democratic National Convention, while a majority views President Trump unfavorably.

  • Heading into the first debate in Cleveland, 44% of voters said they expect Biden to perform best, compared with 41% who said they expect Trump to do better.

  • 86% of voters said their position on the 2020 race was immobile, compared with 14% — including 26% of independents — who said they might change their mind.

When a pro-life Republican pastor doesn’t even want the judges anymore https://t.co/uU6asGaBej pic.twitter.com/lQA1HIRnpM

— Bill Scher (@billscher) September 28, 2020

McKay Coppins/Atlantic:
Trump Secretly Mocks His Christian Supporters
Former aides say that in private, the president has spoken with cynicism and contempt about believers.

“They’re all hustlers,” Trump said.

The president’s alliance with religious conservatives has long been premised on the contention that he takes them seriously, while Democrats hold them in disdain. In speeches and interviews, Trump routinely lavishes praise on conservative Christians, casting himself as their champion. “My administration will never stop fighting for Americans of faith,” he declared at a rally for evangelicals earlier this year. It’s a message his campaign will seek to amplify in the coming weeks as Republicans work to confirm Amy Coney Barrett—a devout, conservative Catholic—to the Supreme Court.

He has no depth. It's impossible to come up with any new insights about him. So what happens when politics is crucially important, but there is little original to say? https://t.co/xJf83iNNOH

— Quinta Jurecic (@qjurecic) September 28, 2020

WaPo:

CDC’s credibility is eroded by internal blunders and external attacks as coronavirus vaccine campaigns loom

For decades, the agency stood at the forefront of fighting disease outbreaks. This time, it’s dealing with a crisis of its own.

The CDC had been preparing for decades for this moment — the arrival of a virus rampaging across the planet, inflicting widespread death and suffering.

But 2020 has been a disaster for the CDC.

The agency’s response to the worst public health crisis in a century — the coronavirus pandemic — has been marked by technical blunders and botched messaging. The agency has endured false accusations and interference by Trump administration political appointees. Worst of all, the CDC has experienced a loss of institutional credibility at a time when the nation desperately needs to know whom to trust.

This harsh assessment does not come from political or ideological enemies of the CDC. It comes from the agency’s friends and supporters — and even from some of the professionals within the agency’s Atlanta headquarters.

“Since late February, the CDC has lost massive amounts of credibility,” said Jody Lanard, a physician who worked for nearly two decades as a pandemic communications adviser consulting with the World Health Organization.

How could it be possible that a conscienceless, remorseless narcissistic psychopath who thinks only of himself, locked children in cages, doesn't care whether Americans die of a deadly disease, and publicly attacked Pope Francis, could hold religious people in such low regard? https://t.co/IJLHLcer1C

— George Conway (@gtconway3d) September 29, 2020

Brian Galle/USA Today:

Trump tax returns are not just good for gossip. Here are 3 reasons voters should care.

Trump didn't want us to know what was in his returns. Was he honest with the IRS? Did hiding information make him a security risk? Is he fit to lead?

A common trick that tax-evading business owners use is to have the business buy things for them directly, and then not report the purchase as income for the owner. In my time as a federal prosecutor, I saw small businesses pay for their owners’ “home office” renovation — actually a lavish kitchen remodel — or for “compensation” for love interests of the owner that were actually just big gifts.

So when we read that the president claimed deductions for hair styling, private jets and big parties at his home, we are seeing behavior typical of expenditures investigators see in tax-evading family businesses. Sometimes these expenses are legitimate. No, you can’t deduct your hair stylist expenses. But for many questionable business expenses, an IRS auditor would have to give the taxpayer a chance to prove that, say, his mansion really is an investment property, not a playground for his adult children.

.@usatodayopinion editorial: Trump routinely overspends, miscalculates and mismanages. His skills as a strategic thinker are nonexistent. OTOH ... He excels in tax avoidance, walking out on debts, self-promotion and playing a successful businessman on TV. https://t.co/CNcnFR1CsY

— Jill Lawrence (@JillDLawrence) September 29, 2020

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: The WH tax scofflaw paid $750 in taxes, owes nearly a billion dollars

Sarah Longwell/The Bulwark:

Scenes from a Supreme Court Focus Group

Talking with nine swing-state voters who went for Trump in 2016 about the coming SCOTUS fight.

When I logged onto the Zoom call I began the discussion with an open-ended question: “How has your thinking about the presidential race changed—or has it—since we last spoke?”

Their answers surprised me. No one even mentioned the Supreme Court. Instead many of the women volunteered that they were leaning much more toward Joe Biden because of Donald Trump’s recent refusal to commit to a peaceful transfer of power.

Their disgust was palpable.

After accusing Biden of being on drugs and Bloomberg of bribery, calling for the impeachment of a senator, repeating his usual vague insinuations about ballots and his usual vague promise of an Obamacare replacement, Trump has arrived at his golf club.

— Daniel Dale (@ddale8) September 27, 2020

good morning, Philadelphia $750, huh? pic.twitter.com/l0nvmiT5XE

— Greg Dworkin (@DemFromCT) September 28, 2020

Way more to come on the big Trump tax story, but a bit early for the pundits on that, so we will turn to twitter.

The report also reveals the Trump Organization wrote off around $26 million in unexplained “consulting fees” between 2010 and 2018. Some of those tax deductions match consulting fees paid to Ivanka Trump in her financial disclosures. https://t.co/kVdcFPPccT

— The Hill (@thehill) September 27, 2020

Otoh, this is a work of art:

Teachers paid $7,239 Firefighters paid $5,283 Nurses paid $10,216 Donald Trump paid $750 pic.twitter.com/5YE1cbYsBN

— Team Joe (Text JOE to 30330) (@TeamJoe) September 28, 2020

I mean, he’s a tax scofflaw and a security risk, but we knew that.

His bankers will have to deal with his failure as a businessman. But handling his failure of a presidency is up to us. It’s voting season.

— Pete Buttigieg (@PeteButtigieg) September 27, 2020

It’s not up to Robert Mueller, voters. It’s up to you. Meanwhile, LOL it all matters.

Should we start a gofundme for the President?

— Rachel Vindman (@natsechobbyist) September 28, 2020

Well, he was losing before the tax story.

You don't need a fancy algorithm to know that Trump is losing, pretty badly at the moment. The Supreme Court pick doesn't seem to be helping him. The COVID situation may be getting worse again. Maybe the debates will help. But the clock is ticking: people are already voting.

— Nate Silver (@NateSilver538) September 27, 2020

From this poll: 1) Biden +12 in 13 battleground states; 2) Biden even in red states Trump won by 11 in 2016; 3) Biden even in veteran and active duty military households. As Kobe would say, job not done.https://t.co/o0DH1guP6y

— John Della Volpe (@dellavolpe) September 27, 2020

Tom Ridge/Philadelphia Inquirer:

I was a Republican governor of Pa. I’m voting for Joe Biden

Whether the Republican Party can restore itself or not, I don’t know. Whether it wants to or not, I don’t know that either. But what matters to me is that the core group of conservative principles I held as a young man when I cast my first vote decades ago are with me today. They are the same principles exhorted by my party’s forebears -- Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt and Ronald Reagan. Those principles have been indispensible to me in deciding to extend my hand of support to Joe Biden, who I believe absolutely must be America’s next president.

The bigger endorsement, of course, is The Rock.

Per new ABC/WP poll, Trump heads into weeks of confirmation fight over preserving #ACA protections for #preexistingconditions w/Biden holding these leads on handling health care: +48 non-whites; +47 col+ white women,+ 26 ages 18-29, +24 indies. Biden's even w/non col white women https://t.co/GNdJAIJAu6

— Ronald Brownstein (@RonBrownstein) September 27, 2020

Margaret Sullivan/WaPo:

Four years ago, Trump survived ‘Access Hollywood’ — and a media myth of indestructibility was born

I come away from all of this — the past four years of shocking scandals and constant lies, the conversations with voters, the media’s beating-our-heads-against-the-wall coverage of Trump voters who still like Trump — with a changed viewpoint about the needle that supposedly doesn’t move.

Actually, it does move.

In looking back at the “Access Hollywood” episode, I came across an academic study published this year by scholars from the University of Massachusetts and Brandeis University that cuts against conventional wisdom. Entitling their paper “Just Locker Room Talk?,” the political scientists concluded that the revelations did make a difference, finding “consistent evidence that the release of the tape modestly, though significantly, reduced support for Donald Trump during the 2016 campaign.” These effects were similar among men and women, but noticeably larger among Republicans compared with Democrats.

Yet another measure of how suburban turnout may soar in Nov. Combined w/a recovery from 16's big decline in Black turnout, it seems very possible that the non-college white vote share, which has been dropping 2 pts every 4 years, could fall 3, creating a deeper hole for Trump. https://t.co/la7HLXO6ck

— Ronald Brownstein (@RonBrownstein) September 27, 2020

Joseph G Allen and Lindsey C.Marr/WaPo:

Yes, airborne transmission is happening. The CDC needs to set the record straight.

But on Monday, the CDC removed this information from its website, bizarrely explaining that it “does not reflect our current state of knowledge.”

So let’s review our current state of knowledge, shall we?

Many scientists have known that airborne transmission of the virus was happening since February. The CDC, however, somehow failed to recognize the accumulating evidence that airborne transmission is important and therefore failed to alert the public.

Breaking news: NO John durham interim report. No indictments before election - Bartiromo sources. @SundayFutures @FoxNews @MorningsMaria @FoxBusiness

— Maria Bartiromo (@MariaBartiromo) September 27, 2020

Michael Grunwald/Politico:

2020 is the Year Trump Was Worried About

If presidential elections really turn on how the country is doing, there's a good reason for the incumbent to sweat.

The U.S. budget deficit tripled this year to $3.3 trillion, by far the highest ever. The U.S. economy shrank at a 31.7 percent annual rate in the second quarter, by far the worst ever. The trade deficit is at its highest level in 12 years. Consumer confidence is at its lowest level in six years. Unemployment claims, which had never topped 700,000 in a week before March, have topped 700,000 every week since March. Farm bankruptcies are rising, even though government payments to farmers are at an all-time high. Homicides are rising in America’s cities after decades of decline, while a series of police killings of unarmed Black Americans has triggered anguished protests and civil unrest. The West Coast is on fire, and 2020 may turn out to be the hottest year in recorded history. America’s reputation abroad is the worst it’s been since the Pew Research Center began doing international surveys.

In related news, a virus that has already killed 200,000 Americans is still spreading in much of the country, even though it’s mostly under control in most of the rest of the world. Now the death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, less than two months before an election that was already inflaming some rather scary tensions, has created a potential constitutional crisis, while President Donald Trump is refusing to commit to a peaceful transition of power if he loses the election to Joe Biden.

Voters are already starting to vote, and the president is already proclaiming that the election is going to be riddled with fraud, which is not so awesome.

On the other hand … let’s see ... Hamilton is streaming on Disney Plus?

Per new ABC/WP poll, Trump heads into weeks of confirmation fight over preserving #ACA protections for #preexistingconditions w/Biden holding these leads on handling health care: +48 non-whites; +47 col+ white women,+ 26 ages 18-29, +24 indies. Biden's even w/non col white women https://t.co/GNdJAIJAu6

— Ronald Brownstein (@RonBrownstein) September 27, 2020

Biden leads Trump 49 to 41 percent nationwide, according to a new New York Times/Siena College pollhttps://t.co/D14kMFXrnw

— Nate Cohn (@Nate_Cohn) September 27, 2020

Takeaways from NBC News/Marist polls of MI & WI 1. Majorities of likely voters say 2020 winner should get to fill SCOTUS vacancy Winner should fill vacancy MI 54%, WI 56% Trump should fill vacancy immediately MI 35%, WI 37% Trump should fill after election MI 7%, WI 5%

— Mark Murray (@mmurraypolitics) September 27, 2020

Marc Lipsitch and Yonatan Grad/WaPo:

How to fix public health weaknesses before the next pandemic hits

The list could go on. The common denominator is an antiquated and unstandardized system of linking data from clinical records and public health monitoring in ways that provide evidence on how to control the virus while minimizing the disruption to the economy and society. Electronic medical records — envisioned as a boon for public-health surveillance, providing data that could be readily analyzed — turn out to be much better for billing than for the exchange of data.

The next phase of pandemic response that might be placed at risk by these spotty data systems is vaccination. Accurate records of who has been vaccinated, when and with which vaccine will be essential. They will encourage trust in the safety and effectiveness of vaccines, ensure prioritization of the groups that should first receive the vaccine, and aid in monitoring vaccine impact on the pandemic. A patchwork of local systems, already strained, is not well-suited to this task.

Natalia Linos/Boston Globe:

COVID-19 is political, so scientists should be too

I ran for Congress because it needs more scientists. But that’s just one of many ways we can have more influence on our government.

Every race is unique, and it is particularly challenging to draw lessons from campaigning during the COVID-19 pandemic, but one thing I learned is that a background in health and an unconventional profile can be appealing to voters across the political spectrum. My campaign found high levels of support with both progressive and more conservative voters, and across the district’s diverse geography. Could having more scientists in Congress, with our focus on evidence and data, help bridge the political divide?

Public health needs a political constituency. Otherwise, the funds won’t be there.

Oh, & like most NYT/Siena state polls, this national survey finds Biden in a strong position even though it has undecided higher for non-white than white voters. The decided voters in those groups give Biden big leads. Where does Trump go for more votes? https://t.co/PP2jntVCFV

— Ronald Brownstein (@RonBrownstein) September 27, 2020

Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: Trump perjury, Postmaster General retreats, a Digital Decency Convention

Ross K Baker/USA Today:

Trump defames US mail system as vulnerable to vote fraud, lays groundwork for coup d'etat

The Founders and Abraham Lincoln understood a Postal Service was important to national unity — especially when that unity is threatened, as it is now.

But the most omnipresent components of the USPS are the letter carriers who deliver the mail to our front doors in all seasons while dodging aggressive dogs and staggering under the avalanche of pre-holiday catalogs. These men and women are the face of the USPS, and we get to know them well. I can recall the first names of every letter carrier who brought my mail in the various places I lived during my adult years. Even those fearful of anyone but a family member appearing at their front door welcome the letter carrier. And the gold standard of promissory statements is “the check is in the mail.”

DeJoy ordered USPS to remove 671 mail sorting machines by end of September, including 24 in Ohio, 11 in Detroit, 11 in Florida, 9 in Wisconsin, 8 in Philadelphia and 5 in Arizona. Will removed mail equipment be restored? DeJoy doesn't say in letter & we need answers

— Ari Berman (@AriBerman) August 18, 2020

The pressure matters, as Postmaster General Louis DeJoy now says no procedural changes prior to the election for appearance’s sake. But will changes be rescinded? Remember, they’ll try to blow it all off as “Y2K paranoia” (attention to which addressed the issues). Hearings Friday (Senate) and Monday (House), with legislation in House planned for Saturday preceding the hearing.

Judy and Dennis Shepard, the parents of the late Matthew Shepard, cast Wyoming’s vote at tonight’s DNC roll call. pic.twitter.com/q1D2e1mFc5

— DJ Judd (@DJJudd) August 19, 2020

Pretty interesting night 2 of the DNC, we’ll talk about it in the comments. But the virtual roll call was great (especially OH, NC and RI and of course, WY). The health care segment with Ady Barkan. And the very normal, very relatable Joe and Jill Biden, from an empty classroom. And (thank god) short speeches. Decency sells, even digital decency.

New: @USPS board member statement: We are working hard to ensure accountability pic.twitter.com/1a4ihMes04

— davidshepardson (@davidshepardson) August 18, 2020

Overtime will continue “as needed”. Hmmm..

Politico:

They felt the heat. And that's what we were trying to do, make it too hot for them to handle,” House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said, reacting to the announcement during a POLITICO Playbook interview.

Earlier Tuesday, a group of state attorneys general announced they were filing a lawsuit over the changes at the USPS, arguing the changes were made unlawfully and without following proper procedure. A spokesperson for Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh told POLITICO “our suit moves forward,” after DeJoy’s announcement.

I don’t think this image is giving the message Rudy intended.😂😂 https://t.co/QW0730pwLP

— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) August 18, 2020

Barbara McQuade/USA Today:

After Trump: All the ways the next president can restore trust in the Justice Department

Sally Yates is a career federal prosecutor who stayed on as acting attorney general during the early days of the current administration. Her assumption that the Department of Justice would be governed by the rule of law turned out to be a bad match for President Donald Trump’s vision. But her attempts to hold to that principle earned her a speaking slot Tuesday night at the Democratic National Convention.

While many Americans may not be familiar with Yates, those of us who devoted our careers to serving the public at DOJ will recognize her. What we barely recognize is the current incarnation of the only Cabinet agency named for an ideal. That’s why some of us have put together a blueprint for reviving trust there.

It’s harder to state it more clearly than this:

BREAKING: Putin ordered the 2016 hacking of Democratic Party accounts and the release of emails intended to harm Hillary Clinton’s campaign, the Senate Intelligence Committee concluded https://t.co/hY8xkriQub

— Bloomberg (@business) August 18, 2020

“it appears quite likely that Stone and Trump spoke about Wikileaks.” In other words, Trump lied to Mueller. That’s a major finding by a bipartisan Senate committee. https://t.co/lRVChfFnSR

— Dan Shallman (@danshallman) August 18, 2020

This was a bipartisan finding. That Republican Intel Senators knew this but refused to call for witnesses or convict on impeachment is another story. And that this is still going on is another story, indeed.

Guardian:

Louis DeJoy: is Trump's new post office chief trying to rig the election?

Since taking office in June, DeJoy has executed sweeping changes at the struggling USPS, leading to delays in mail delivery – and fears mail-in ballots won’t arrive on time

About a month ago, a United States Postal Service (USPS) mail carrier named Mark arrived at his post office in central Pennsylvania and got some shocking news from his station manager. Mark and his coworkers were told they would have to depart the office for deliveries a few hours earlier each day, even if that meant leaving behind much of the day’s mail.

In the weeks that followed, higher-ups at the station instructed carriers to abandon hundreds of pieces of mail in order to depart a mere 10 or 20 minutes earlier. As the days went on, the excess mail started to pile up, and now Mark estimates there are thousands of undelivered letters and packages sitting in his station.

“The supervisors are cracking the whip, making sure we leave,” Mark told the Guardian. “Meanwhile carriers are walking by and saying, ‘Look at all this fucking mail we’re walking past, it’s just sitting there.’”

Keep in mind the new Republican talking point is that it’s all postal efficiency, and not the ‘fevered election stealing’ that Democrats are making up. But that’s what happens when you only talk to management and not labor. It’s really a twofer: sabotage the USPS to go private, and slow ballots down as a bonus.

Biden leads Trump among women, minorities, college-educated whites, and former members of the Trump administration.

— Windsor Mann (@WindsorMann) August 18, 2020

Miles Taylor/WaPo:

At Homeland Security, I saw firsthand how dangerous Trump is for America
The president’s bungled response to the coronavirus pandemic is the ultimate example. In his cavalier disregard for the seriousness of the threat, Trump failed to make effective use of the federal crisis response system painstakingly built after 9/11. Years of DHS planning for a pandemic threat have been largely wasted. Meanwhile, more than 165,000 Americans have died.

This is exactly right. Few undecideds/swing voters are watching party conventions because they tend to be the least engaged/partisan voters. So seeing next-day headlines and reading/watching coverage is more important. https://t.co/PNzh8W6AlZ

— Geoffrey Skelley (@geoffreyvs) August 18, 2020

Niskanen Center:

Niskanen Center/JMC Analytics and Polling Survey of Rural Voters on USPS & COVID19

 Despite a party breakdown of 56% Republican, 34% Democrat in this survey, reflecting the rural Pennsylvania congressional districts sampled, 57% of these likely 2020 voters report they’d be less likely to support a candidate who reduced the budget for the U.S Postal Service, or privatized theagency, including 43% of Republicans.

 52% of these likely voters report they are “not likely at all” to vote by mail this fall, driven almost entirely by Republican voters’ strong rejection of the option. 68% of Republicans report they are“not at all likely” to vote by mail while 53% of Democrats say they are “very likely.”

 53% of rural voters say they are “very” or “somewhat” reliant on USPS service. Rural Republicans profess much less reliance on USPS than rural Democrats -- just 17% of Republicans report being“very” reliant while 43% of “Democrats” say the same, indicating a party effect.

WE ARE SO ON TOP OF THIS PANDEMIC, YOU GUYS https://t.co/I3ttlcRrkO

— Maggie Koerth (@maggiekb1) August 18, 2020

Greg Sargent/WaPo:

Trump’s unhinged Twitter meltdown shows Michelle Obama drew blood

President Trump unleashed a torrent of rage tweets about Michelle Obama’s speech at the Democratic convention that was spectacularly cringeworthy even by his standards — but it only underscored how effectively the former first lady made the case against him, in ways that are significant but not immediately apparent.

The strength of her scorching indictment of Trump — delivered on Monday night — resides in the fact that everyone, or at least a majority, knows it is true. As Trump’s meltdown shows, his only available response is to swap in an entirely invented tale, one hermetically sealed off from reality in just about every conceivable way.

Her case, boiled down, is that Trump inherited a country that, for all its deep problems and lingering inequalities, was on the mend following another previous crisis. Trump proceeded to utterly wreck the place through his incompetence, malevolence, corruption and depraved conviction that stoking as much civil conflict and racial incitement as possible helps him.

My Pillow creator, Mike Lindell defends promoting an unproven therapeutic. “Why would I ruin my reputation?" .@andersoncooper: “You don't have a great reputation, sir."

— Bianna Golodryga (@biannagolodryga) August 18, 2020